Unlike in some other jurisdictions, English law does not imply a general duty of good faith into contracts. This is to avoid uncertainty and preserve parties’ freedom to pursue their own commercial interests (within their contractual framework). However, as discussed in a 2023 High Court judgment, a duty of good faith may be implied into “relational” contracts in certain circ*mstances. The uncertainty around the English courts’ willingness to imply a term into a contract requiring a party to act in good faith means that parties should give thought at the point of negotiating a contract as to whether they should include an express duty of good faith in relation to some, or all, of the contractual obligations. If a duty of good faith is expressly included, parties should be clear about its intended scope. Giving careful thought to these issues when negotiating contracts can mitigate the risk of disputes arising as to whether a duty of good faith applies and the scope of such a duty. In Phones 4U Ltd (In Administration) (P4U) v EE Ltd and others (EE)1, the High Court held that the relevant agreement was not a relational contract and EE was not under a general duty to act in good faith. EE had informed P4U that they would not extend their existing trading agreement (pursuant to which EE paid P4U to sell mobile phone contracts to new customers or upgrade existing customers’ contracts). P4U claimed that by seeking to terminate the contract a year before it was due to end, EE was trying to force P4U into administration and avoid making further payments. P4U argued that the agreement was relational in nature and as such, EE was under an implied general duty to act in good faith when performing its contractual obligations. EE denied the claims, including on the basis that the contract did in fact contain an express duty of good faith, but that this was limited to the context of activities designed to reduce P4U’s revenue. Therefore, no broader duty of good faith could be implied. The judge agreed with EE’s position. First, although he acknowledged that some features of a relational contract existed, for example it was long term and required the parties to collaborate, he decided that the contract was not relational - observing that: The judge went on to say that, even if the agreement was relational in nature, it would not affect the outcome. This was for two reasons: Parties to an English law contract are not under any general duty to act in good faith in performing that contract. However, a duty to act in good faith can arise in three situations: This judgment is significant as it provides more detail on the factors to be considered when assessing whether a contract is relational in nature. For example, the judge noted that whether any competition exists between the parties is a relevant factor, as is whether or not the parties have given thought to how they will cooperate (i.e., specifying certain obligations rather than imposing a general duty to collaborate). Further, the case shows that a party cannot rely on a specific duty to act in good faith as a basis of demonstrating that a general good faith obligation applies to the contract. Where express good faith duties are included, parties should ensure that those provisions are clearly drafted to ensure that the agreement reflects the parties’ intentions as to the scope of that duty. This should help mitigate the risk of claims being brought on the basis of an alleged implied duty of good faith in relation to contracts where such a duty was never intended to apply. 1 [2023] EWHC 2826 (Ch).Introduction
Key takeaways
Phones 4U v EE Ltd and others
Why it is significant
Good faith and relational contracts explored in Phones 4U v EE Limited and others | DLA Piper (2024)
Top Articles
Lottie Moss and Elle MacPherson bring the glamour in sheer dresses
Inattendu : pourquoi la plantation d'arbres peut-elle aggraver la qualité de l'air dans les zones urbaines ?
Average Jonas Wife
Asist Liberty
Garrison Blacksmith Bench
Fat People Falling Gif
Booknet.com Contract Marriage 2
Ymca Sammamish Class Schedule
PRISMA Technik 7-10 Baden-Württemberg
Ashlyn Peaks Bio
Calamity Hallowed Ore
Employeeres Ual
Day Octopus | Hawaii Marine Life
Culos Grandes Ricos
Ssefth1203
Yesteryear Autos Slang
Hair Love Salon Bradley Beach
Magic Mike's Last Dance Showtimes Near Marcus Cedar Creek Cinema
800-695-2780
Mail.zsthost Change Password
Aucklanders brace for gales, hail, cold temperatures, possible blackouts; snow falls in Chch
SF bay area cars & trucks "chevrolet 50" - craigslist
Daytonaskipthegames
Pecos Valley Sunland Park Menu
Minnick Funeral Home West Point Nebraska
Obituaries Milwaukee Journal Sentinel
Phantom Fireworks Of Delaware Watergap Photos
Finding Safety Data Sheets
Sam's Club Near Wisconsin Dells
Ghid depunere declarație unică
Unm Hsc Zoom
LEGO Star Wars: Rebuild the Galaxy Review - Latest Animated Special Brings Loads of Fun With An Emotional Twist
Sun Haven Pufferfish
Tamilrockers Movies 2023 Download
Sitting Human Silhouette Demonologist
No Hard Feelings Showtimes Near Tilton Square Theatre
Wal-Mart 2516 Directory
11301 Lakeline Blvd Parkline Plaza Ctr Ste 150
Aurora Il Back Pages
St Anthony Hospital Crown Point Visiting Hours
511Pa
Nid Lcms
manhattan cars & trucks - by owner - craigslist
Promo Code Blackout Bingo 2023
Free Crossword Puzzles | BestCrosswords.com
Dickdrainersx Jessica Marie
Penny Paws San Antonio Photos
Cleveland Save 25% - Lighthouse Immersive Studios | Buy Tickets
Avance Primary Care Morrisville
Petfinder Quiz
26 Best & Fun Things to Do in Saginaw (MI)
Zalog Forum
Latest Posts
A Very Royal Scandal first look as release date is revealed
Sie fand ihr Glück: Vor 25 Jahren trat Tennisstar Steffi Graf zurück
Article information
Author: Cheryll Lueilwitz
Last Updated:
Views: 5613
Rating: 4.3 / 5 (74 voted)
Reviews: 81% of readers found this page helpful
Author information
Name: Cheryll Lueilwitz
Birthday: 1997-12-23
Address: 4653 O'Kon Hill, Lake Juanstad, AR 65469
Phone: +494124489301
Job: Marketing Representative
Hobby: Reading, Ice skating, Foraging, BASE jumping, Hiking, Skateboarding, Kayaking
Introduction: My name is Cheryll Lueilwitz, I am a sparkling, clean, super, lucky, joyous, outstanding, lucky person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.